by Keith Porteous Wood, National Secular Society
The Pope should of course be free to visit France and his Catholic clerics and flock here.
But there are numerous reasons why it is neither appropriate nor legitimate for the President of theoretically secular France to invite here, for a state visit, this absolute monarch of a minuscule non-democratic European country, practically the only one not to have felt morally obliged to ratify the European Convention on Human Rights.
Let us start with cost. Why should the state (and especially the 98% of the population who are not weekly mass goers) pay enormous amounts for police, security and presumably the Pope’s round trip by plane from Rome to Paris, Metz and Lourdes? Even the cost – not to mention the wholly unwarranted inconvenience – of closing off the Place de la Concorde and large parts of the Avenue de la Grande Armée and of the Champs Elysees for a mass must be huge.
The French Catholic Church is bearing some costs for other events but why not the whole cost? It is hardly as if it can’t afford it. Despite its duplicitous and manipulative claims to poverty when it comes to paying out abuse victims, its cash, investments and sellable real estate are estimated to total 7.5 billion Euros.
And while we are on the question of costs, it is well past time to rescind the Concordat that France foolishly took over post WWI, resulting in its paying clerics’ salaries for Alsace Moselle. And maybe also time to consider handing the churches back to the Church, together with the responsibility for maintaining these generally poorly attended buildings.
Why should the state sponsor the visit when the majority of the population are not even believers? There would be more justification for inviting leading atheist Richard Dawkins, but I am not suggesting that either.
The Church’s popularity continues to sink at a significant rate – in the 1950s mass attendance was 25%, but now just 2%. Much of this decline has been the public’s very reasonable revulsion at the obscene levels of sexual abuse of children by clerics, compounded by the Church going to inordinate lengths to protect them from criminal prosecution.
Even the French RCC admitted recently that since 1950 there had been 1/3 million childhood victims of RCC clerical abuse – so therefore presumably over a million abuses. In my view this preposterous invitation for an official visit is an insult to every one of those victims. How can the President not see that? How many more victims would there have to have been for the President to have refused to sponsor a state visit?
The unpalatable answer is that I suspect to him the number is irrelevant. The Church is above the law, as evidenced by those million abuses resulting in only a minuscule number of prosecutions, far less convictions. The police, prosecutors and courts all looked, and continue to look, the other way.
We saw the Church being above the law again when Cardinal Barbarin’s conviction was, in my opinion baselessly, overturned by France’s Cour de Cassation. He did not deny having failed to report knowledge of the abuse including rape of probably 3,000 male scouts over decades by priest Bernard Preynat, as his predecessor had also known.
Another example is members of both Houses of Parliament who despite overwhelming evidence of widespread clerical abuse of minors callously and negligently betrayed the victims by failing to instigate a national independent enquiry as many other European countries did.
And then there is the Government itself which was asked formally both in writing and verbally on more than one occasion by the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child to respond to criticisms of its handling of clerical abuse.(6) It blatantly failed to respond, clearly to avoid embarrassing the Church rather than engage with the Committee on measures that could aid past and future childhood victims of clerical abuse.
My penultimate point concerns former French PM François Bayrou. An official report concluded he had failed to act on systemic physical and sexual abuse – even torture – at the Catholic boarding school, Bétherram near Pau. Rapporteur Vannier concluded it to be “far from being a unique case”, that there had been major “failings” by the French state, the justice system and the education ministry, which failed to implement proper checks and controls … at every level “from the local level right up to the highest levels of state”. Former education minister Bayrou denied knowing of the abuse despite evidence to the contrary.
It gives me no pleasure whatsoever to now turn to the President himself. Instead of supporting the calls for far stronger measures to prevent further abuse, he instead chose predictably to “denounce what he calls a political campaign of ‘destruction’ against [Bayrou]”.
Under Emmanuel Macron France’s claim to be a secular country has suffered a severe setback, as similarly has the US. The flag bearer is now Québec, but of course it is under pressure from the Supreme Court of Canada to become less secular.
Let us conclude on an optimistic note, with Macron’s term ending in the Spring. Let us seek to make a restoration of France’s secularity a key demand for his successor.
But they will face a gigantic task.